Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Senator accuses Woolworths CEO of dodging questions
ABC NEWS (Australia)
Follow
4/16/2024
The chair of a senate supermarket pricing inquiry has threatened to hold the outgoing boss of Woolworths in contempt after a fiery exchange about Woolies profit margins.
Category
📺
TV
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
Quite a fiery morning in the Senate in the inquiry into supermarket pricing. It all launched
00:09
around nine this morning when the chair of that inquiry, Senator Nick McKim, started
00:16
asking the outgoing boss of Woolworths, Brad Banducci, if he knew the return on equity
00:22
for the supermarket retailer. Now, Mr Banducci initially said, well, that's not really something
00:30
we focus on here at Woolworths in terms of measuring our profitability, saying that instead
00:36
they like to look at other ways of measuring how well the company is doing. Clearly, the
00:43
senator was not going to let this one go and insisted that his understanding of the return
00:50
on equity for Woolworths was around 26%, which is far higher even than some of the major
00:57
banks. And the senator insisted that this showed that potentially Woolworths was price
01:03
gouging. Again, Mr Banducci insisted it's not something they really focus on at the
01:08
company and declined to essentially say whether yes or no, he believed that the return on
01:15
equity was 26%. This just went on for so long, Casey, and eventually we had this fiery moment
01:22
from the senator towards Mr Banducci.
01:24
I repeatedly refused to answer my question on return on equity. I feel compelled to advise
01:31
you that it is open to the Senate to hold a witness in contempt when they refuse to
01:38
answer a legitimate question. Having said that, I ask you again, is your return on equity
01:50
in the last financial year about 26%?
01:54
Senator, I've answered the question many times.
01:57
You have not answered the question, Mr Banducci. Honestly, I'm not interested in your spin
02:04
or your bullshit. This is a Senate inquiry.
02:09
Quite the exchange there, Amelia, it turns on. So the committee took a break after that,
02:13
but they have since returned. What's happened since?
02:16
So they did take a break. Then they returned around 11 o'clock, I believe. And then with
02:23
more questions about return on equity, this very technical financial measurement, the
02:28
suddenly Mr Senator Nick McKim called a sudden snap break to discuss what they were going
02:35
to do about this back and forth about this technical term. They then came back. And here
02:41
is eventually the moment where it appears that this situation was resolved two hours
02:46
later.
02:47
I think your evidence to the committee is you don't know what the return on equity was
02:53
for Woolworths in the last financial year. And you would like to take the question on
02:57
notice. Could you please just answer yes or no, whether that is your evidence to the committee?
03:02
Senator, yes, I will take it on notice and we will come back and provide another.
03:08
Yes. Just to be clear. Yes. When you say yes, that is yes, I do not know. And yes, you will
03:14
take it on notice. Are you answering yes to both parts of that question?
03:19
Yes, Senator.
03:20
OK, thank you, Mr Banducci. You don't know what the ROE for Woolworths is.
03:30
So yeah, an apparent admission there that the Woolworths CEO doesn't know one of those
03:34
financial metrics of his company, at least off the top of his head. Amelia, I imagine
03:39
this is not the only thing the Woolworths CEO was grilled on.
03:42
No, Casey. We also had a lot of questions from various senators about allegations already
03:49
heard through this inquiry, namely by the CEO of Metcash, which runs IGA, that the major
03:56
supermarkets are participating in land banking. This is where companies go up and buy land
04:03
and they have no real desire to develop it or put a store on it. They're simply buying
04:08
up this land to keep out their competition. Mr Banducci denied that Woolworths is participating
04:14
in land banking. We also had a lot of questions, as you might imagine, about how the supermarket
04:21
is treating its suppliers. While this inquiry has, as its name would suggest, been to look
04:28
into supermarket pricing, we have heard so many reports from growers throughout this
04:34
inquiry that they are being squeezed. Indeed, we've had some growers of things like citrus
04:39
say they haven't really received nominal increases on what they get from the supermarkets for
04:43
more than a decade. So there was lots of conversation about how the supermarket is treating its
04:48
suppliers. We did have Mr Banducci say they believe that they practice in good faith with
04:55
their suppliers. However, they did say that potentially they need to do more with less
04:59
sophisticated or smaller suppliers. We have now had Mr Banducci, it appears, finish for
05:05
the day. And now next up, we have the boss of Coles appearing before this inquiry.
05:10
- Thank you.
05:11
[BLANK_AUDIO]
Recommended
1:00
|
Up next
Woolworths CEO threatened with jail time during senate inquiry into supermarket pricing
Australian Community Media
4/16/2024
0:55
Aussie shopper confronts Woolworths CEO in busy supermarket
Australian Community Media
9/30/2024
1:34
Debate become fiery during a Senate inquiry into supermarket prices
The Canberra Times
4/16/2024
3:25
Woolworths seeks Fair Work orders to clear Melbourne picket line
ABC NEWS (Australia)
12/3/2024
3:48
ACCC takes Woolworths and Coles to court over discount claims
ABC NEWS (Australia)
9/23/2024
1:00
'Shut them down': anger over Coles and Woolworths $1.2 billion profit
Australian Community Media
8/30/2024
3:23
Senate supermarket inquiry hearing from producers in NSW Central West
ABC NEWS (Australia)
3/12/2024
2:01
Woolworths CEO announces he is leaving after nine years in the top job
ABC NEWS (Australia)
2/21/2024
1:29
More empty shelves ahead in WA supermarkets as Coles and Woolworths try to restock stores
ABC NEWS (Australia)
4/17/2024
1:00
Woolworths CEO storms out of interview about sky-high grocery prices
Australian Community Media
2/19/2024
2:04
Supermarkets face accusations of price gouging
ABC NEWS (Australia)
6/20/2024
1:35
As Woolworths faces Christmas with empty shelves, it is asking Fair Work to order its staff back onto the job
ABC NEWS (Australia)
12/6/2024
1:39
New study finds Woolworths prices are higher compared to a year ago
ABC NEWS (Australia)
3/27/2025
2:07
ACCC sues Woolworths, Coles over alleged misleading pricing
ABC NEWS (Australia)
9/23/2024
1:13
Queensland Premier orders inquiry into supermarket prices
ABC NEWS (Australia)
1/19/2024
2:12
Supermarket seeks Fair Work orders to clear Melbourne picket line
ABC NEWS (Australia)
12/3/2024
1:44
Woolworths workers strike as Australian supermarket giants are facing increased pressure over their treatment of suppliers
ABC NEWS (Australia)
11/22/2024
0:46
Woolworths CEO Brad Banducci quits top job after trainwreck interview
Australian Community Media
2/20/2024
2:02
Greens push for federal inquiry into supermarket price gouging
ABC NEWS (Australia)
12/2/2023
3:13
Woolworths workers picket distribution centre in Melbourne as industrial dispute continues
ABC NEWS (Australia)
12/2/2024
1:31
Report finds Aldi significantly cheaper than Coles, Woolworths
ABC NEWS (Australia)
6/20/2024
1:32
Supermarkets see thefts arise amid cost of living crisis
ABC NEWS (Australia)
8/24/2023
2:10
Woolworths and Coles taken to Federal Court over 'misleading' price discounts
Australian Community Media
9/23/2024
2:52
Residents and shopkeepers react to Hawker Woolworths proposal
The Canberra Times
3/22/2024
2:42
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese speaks after ACCC announces supermarket court action
Australian Community Media
9/23/2024