• last year
These video games went overboard on the microtransactions. Welcome to WatchMojo, and today we’re counting down our picks for games that charge you upfront and then expect you to keep paying on top of that. We’re including games that have had their microtransactions scaled back, changed, or even removed since receiving backlash.
Transcript
00:00 Welcome to WatchMojo and today we're counting down our picks for games that charge you upfront
00:12 and then expect you to keep paying on top of that.
00:15 We're including games that have had their microtransactions scaled back, changed or
00:19 even removed since receiving backlash.
00:22 20.
00:30 EA Sports FC 2024
00:39 In 2022, it came out that EA wasn't going to be making FIFA games anymore over a failed
00:44 licensing agreement.
00:45 This put an end to a relationship going back to 1993 that had amassed over $20 billion
00:49 in revenue from the franchise.
00:51 EA didn't stop making soccer games though.
00:53 2023 saw the release of this non-FIFA football title.
00:57 But would ditching FIFA mean that Sports FC wouldn't be so relentlessly monetized?
01:01 No, of course not.
01:10 FIFA points are now FC points and they're just as expensive as they were before.
01:15 It's still arguably pay-to-win too, with the best players included in packs that take a
01:18 long time to earn in-game.
01:20 Though many fans say that no matter how much money you spend, if you're bad at the game,
01:25 you'll still lose.
01:30 19.
01:34 The Elder Scrolls IV Oblivion
01:36 We're not just counting outrageously expensive microtransactions as ridiculous.
01:48 Oblivion really didn't have many, though it did have two popular expansions, Knights of
01:52 the Nine and Shivering Isles.
01:54 But you know what we're talking about here, the horse armor.
02:02 This was one of the earliest cosmetic microtransactions in gaming, particularly in a single-player
02:06 game and people were as confused as they were angry.
02:15 For the low price of $250, you could acquire some golden armor for your horse.
02:19 According to Todd Howard, charging for the horse armor was Microsoft's decision, not
02:24 Bethesda's, but the ramifications of including that horse armor in a single-player game are
02:28 still being felt to date, even if hardly anybody bought it.
02:33 18.
02:35 Street Fighter X Tekken
02:43 Paying for additional characters in a fighting game is nothing new.
02:46 Usually, we expect that following a game's release, the developers are hard at work building
02:50 the new characters that fans want so that there's real value for money where DLC is
02:54 concerned.
02:55 But that wasn't the case with Street Fighter X Tekken.
03:01 The game was a lot of fun, unless you were playing it on PC, but it eventually came out
03:06 that 12 of the characters Capcom decided to release as DLC were already on the game disc
03:10 at launch.
03:11 They were blocking off existing content on purpose so that they could charge us an extra
03:15 $20 for it.
03:19 17.
03:21 Batman - Arkham Knight
03:22 Luckily, Arkham Knight's microtransactions were never very intrusive.
03:32 It's pretty easy to completely ignore them and have a good time.
03:35 But just because you can ignore something doesn't mean it's okay.
03:38 The problem here is that there are a lot of premium Batmobile skins, but you can only
03:42 equip and use those skins, which feature many iconic versions of the car, in the Riddler's
03:46 Challenge races.
03:53 You can use them in the open world after you destroy every single tank drone, which is
03:57 necessary from a gameplay perspective because the alternate skins have no tank mode functionality.
04:02 But should we really be charged real money for something that isn't usable 95% of the
04:06 time, or should they have been in the base game?
04:12 16.
04:15 Assassin's Creed Valhalla
04:22 Like Arkham Knight, it's not too hard to ignore the microtransactions in Assassin's
04:26 Creed.
04:27 But why does a series like Assassin's Creed need microtransactions in the first place?
04:31 Well, obviously, it's so that Ubisoft can make even more money by locking away some
04:35 of the coolest weapons and armor sets behind a paywall.
04:43 It's true that these items offer minimal changes to the gameplay, nor are they pay-to-win
04:47 since Valhalla has no multiplayer.
04:49 But we still don't think they should be there.
04:50 The game's expensive enough on its own, not to mention its equally costly large expansions.
04:55 They offer value for money, but the Helix Store and the non-stop XP boosts definitely
05:00 don't.
05:06 15.
05:08 GTA Online
05:16 There are many gamers who resent GTA Online for its success.
05:19 And we don't doubt that there are many diehard fans of GTA Online who still don't think
05:23 the online mode's success should come at the expense of the single player.
05:27 But try telling that to Rockstar and Take-Two.
05:36 Though GTA Online offers plenty of new content in the form of its heists and unique vehicles,
05:40 it's definitely sketchy that you're charged real money, sometimes a lot of real money,
05:45 to buy in-game currency.
05:46 You don't actually need to do this because you'll earn enough through the game to buy
05:50 everything.
05:51 But for whatever reason, people are still tempted, and Rockstar won't say no to that
05:55 extra cash.
06:00 14.
06:02 Overwatch
06:03 Crucially, Overwatch is now a free-to-play game.
06:13 Or rather, Overwatch 2 is.
06:15 This change came after years of Blizzard being criticized for its loot box model, something
06:19 which has since been legislated against in many countries.
06:22 You now unlock new characters and skins by either playing the game a ton or buying each
06:26 season pass.
06:35 But there's something to be said for the way Blizzard updated the original game with
06:38 its sequel, meaning that the original version is no longer playable anywhere.
06:42 It might be free now, but if you bought it during the six years that it wasn't, it's
06:46 not as if you got a refund.
06:47 And it shouldn't be overlooked how predatory those loot boxes were while they existed.
06:55 13.
06:57 Diablo 3
06:58 Thankfully, Diablo 3 isn't like this anymore, and Diablo 4 has been a huge success.
07:10 But the game had many problems at the beginning, chief among them its auction house feature.
07:15 Essentially, players could sell and buy in-game items through one of its two auction houses
07:19 for real money.
07:29 You didn't even need in-game currency as a go-between.
07:32 Unsurprisingly, people were outraged, and this wasn't even legal in some countries
07:36 under gambling laws.
07:38 Blizzard was also skimming off the top of these purchases and taking a 15% cut.
07:42 To everyone's relief, the entire system was axed in 2014, but it definitely wounded
07:47 Blizzard's reputation and hurt the game.
07:53 12.
07:57 Mortal Kombat 1
08:04 There are plenty of games that let you pay for new animations through the form of emotes.
08:08 So to a layperson, NetherRealm adding paid fatalities in Mortal Kombat 1 may not look
08:13 too damning.
08:14 But fatalities are the bread and butter of the franchise, and having to pay extra to
08:18 get new, seasonal fatalities was more than many gamers could stomach.
08:25 And how much was this Halloween finisher?
08:27 About 1,200 Dragon Crystals.
08:29 That's almost $10.
08:31 Worse, later updates to the game locked other things behind paywalls like various skins.
08:36 It looks as if this was all Warner Bros' decision, and they only slightly rolled it
08:40 back in the following months by giving away some new seasonal fatalities for free.
08:48 11.
08:52 Crash Team Racing Nitro-Fueled
09:00 There's nothing slimier than releasing a well-made, hugely popular game, waiting a few weeks for
09:04 all the positive reviews and praise to come in, and then shoving microtransactions in
09:08 after the fact.
09:09 But we'd expect nothing less from Activision.
09:12 That's exactly what the company did to Crash Team Racing, adding microtransactions a month
09:16 later after it had received glowing praise.
09:23 And as far as microtransactions go, they're not that bad.
09:26 But let's not forget, this game is rated E for Everyone.
09:29 That means that, inevitably, very young players are going to be faced with microtransactions,
09:33 which makes the decision look even worse.
09:39 10.
09:44 Gran Turismo 7
09:53 When you pay top dollar for a brand new racing game on release, you expect that you'll
09:56 be able to earn every car yourself, even if it takes a lot of time and effort to do that.
10:01 But that may have not been possible in Gran Turismo 7, which locked many of its cars behind
10:05 paywalls… kind of.
10:13 You definitely can buy the cars by earning in-game credits, but the prices are so steep
10:18 that you're all but forced to instead spend real money on virtual currency.
10:21 If you did want to buy credits to then buy a virtual car, you might be spending hundreds
10:25 of dollars.
10:26 The microtransactions changed, and players were compensated with $10 worth of credits,
10:30 but people haven't forgotten.
10:35 10.
10:39 Call of Duty Modern Warfare 3
10:51 The Call of Duty franchise is a little complex where monetization is concerned.
10:54 On the one hand, Activision is still putting out full-priced annual releases, but it's
10:59 also got Warzone, which is free to play.
11:01 But does the existence of Warzone mean that microtransactions in the main game should
11:04 be scrapped?
11:05 Or even that the annual release cycle should be stopped entirely, which they keep promising
11:09 to do?
11:10 Maybe, but that hasn't happened yet.
11:18 Like previous games, Modern Warfare 3 has a Battle Pass system offering you COD points
11:23 to buy expensive bundles full of cosmetics.
11:25 The game has almost no new content, either.
11:27 It's just a way for Activision to get money for nothing.
11:34 8.
11:38 Middle-Earth Shadow of War
11:46 This is another case of a game where you really don't need to invest in microtransactions
11:50 to do well or have fun.
11:52 Shadow of War may not have reached the lofty heights of Shadow of Mordor, but it was a
11:55 worthy successor nonetheless.
11:57 It did, however, have microtransactions for a while, with numerous tiers of loot boxes
12:02 or "chests" that offered everything from consumables to powerful orcs.
12:10 This was missing the point of the game, since a lot of the fun comes from recruiting specific
12:14 orcs and building out your following.
12:16 Thankfully, by the following summer, all of this was gone.
12:19 If you play Shadow of War today, there's no trace of those pesky loot boxes.
12:26 7.
12:29 Dead Space 3
12:36 The first two Dead Space games are masterpieces of the survival horror genre.
12:39 Taunt, dark, and scary, they were the epitome of survival horror.
12:43 And then Dead Space 3 all but eliminated the survival aspect with the promise of god-like
12:47 items if you just forked over a few extra bucks.
12:50 Crafting weapons is a major aspect of the game, and the game allows you to bypass exploration
12:54 in favor of simply purchasing the necessary components to craft better weapons.
13:08 This completely negates the survival aspect of the game and eliminates any sort of tension,
13:12 exploration, or fear.
13:14 When you can simply purchase the best gun around, what could you possibly be scared
13:18 of?
13:22 6.
13:25 Metal Gear Survive
13:35 Microtransactions began to creep into the series back in 2015 with Metal Gear Solid
13:39 V, where you could buy Mother Base coins to upgrade your HQ.
13:42 But after Konami acrimoniously cut ties with Hideo Kojima, there was no one to stop them
13:47 from making Metal Gear survive.
13:49 What resulted was a critical and commercial bomb, where you mindlessly fought zombies
13:52 and paid a premium for the privilege.
14:02 But not only was the game plain bad, you can buy boost passes that increase how much Kooban
14:06 energy you get.
14:07 Essentially, you're paying real money to level up and upgrade faster, as opposed to
14:11 earning your way to the top.
14:15 Yikes.
14:18 5.
14:20 Deus Ex - Mankind Divided
14:26 Human Revolution was a game that struggled to find its audience.
14:29 It's a top-tier experience, sure, but it was caught between trying to be a hardcore
14:33 immersive sim and something more commercially friendly.
14:42 Part of this conflict manifested in Square Enix seemingly insisting that Eidos add pre-order
14:46 bonus weapons and mission packs to that first game.
14:49 But the sequel, Mankind Divided, went even further, adding microtransaction packs which
14:53 allowed you to purchase in-game credits, weapons, and even praxis kits.
14:57 Essentially, buying experience.
14:59 The only silver lining is that you don't need any of this extra stuff and can have
15:03 even more fun without paying for it.
15:06 4.
15:08 Need for Speed - Payback
15:16 EA had a tough 2017 when it came to gamer goodwill due to their greedy microtransactions.
15:25 Need for Speed was no exception, as players noticed that Payback's progression system
15:29 was far harsher and more restrictive than in games past.
15:38 Suddenly it took a curiously long time to unlock upgrades, and there was always the
15:42 allure of microtransactions in the sidelines should you wish to accelerate the process.
15:46 The response was so toxic that EA altered the progression system, increasing the amount
15:50 of rep and bank given to players and dishing out more frequent air suspension in shipments.
15:55 But by that point, the damage had already been done.
16:01 3.
16:06 Evolve
16:13 Evolve was meant to be the next big multiplayer experience, similar to Left 4 Dead's surprisingly
16:17 fun and expansive Versus mode.
16:19 What we got instead was the shell of a good game, which required you to pay double to
16:23 get the full experience.
16:24 The DLC and microtransactions were enough to bring the entire experience crashing down.
16:35 The season pass cost $25 and gave you access to 4 unique monsters, also sold separately
16:39 for $7.50, and skins.
16:42 The game also forced you to purchase skins for your monsters and weapons, something which
16:45 could have easily been made available through a progression system similar to Call of Duty.
16:53 2.
16:56 NBA 2K24
17:05 If you thought soccer games were bad, wait until you get a load of NBA.
17:09 Each year, 2K manages to defy expectations for how it's going to continually monetize
17:13 a game that remains a full-priced retail release.
17:16 2K24 is the worst so far, adding even more options to pay outright to upgrade your character
17:21 through its badges.
17:29 You need in-game currency to do this, and you get very little from actually playing,
17:33 meaning that you're at a massive disadvantage if you're not constantly paying to keep upgrading.
17:38 And again, people criticized how little the NBA games change every year, recharging you
17:43 $70 every time you want to buy the newest one.
17:52 Before we continue, be sure to subscribe to our channel and ring the bell to get notified
17:57 about our latest videos.
17:58 You have the option to be notified for occasional videos or all of them.
18:02 If you're on your phone, make sure to go into your settings and switch on notifications.
18:07 1.
18:09 Star Wars Battlefront 2
18:13 Battlefront 2 still lives in infamy as one of the most egregious examples of microtransactions,
18:17 one of the few games that had true pay-to-win mechanics at launch.
18:20 If you had the money, you could buy better, more powerful items, giving you a very clear
18:24 advantage over everybody else.
18:28 EA is unpopular at the best of times, but the backlash over Battlefront 2 was extraordinary.
18:37 Microtransactions were pulled completely, but not for long.
18:40 Six months on from the game's release, and EA put them back, though they'd been significantly
18:44 overhauled to only apply to cosmetic items.
18:47 If you waited until 2019, though, you could buy a version that had all the cosmetics in
18:52 it as standard, if only EA had learned its lesson.
19:02 Let us know in the comments if you think microtransactions should be banned completely in paid games.
19:09 In the mood for more awesome gaming content?
19:19 Be sure to check out this video here on Mojo Plays.
19:23 And don't forget to subscribe and ring the bell to be notified about our latest videos.
19:27 See you next time!
19:35 [MUSIC PLAYING]