Another MP ejected from Parliament after war of words

The Star

After a 15-minute shouting match, Pengkalan Chepa MP Datuk Ahmad Marzuk Shaary was ejected from Parliament on Monday (Nov 6) after he refused to retract his remarks against Local Government Development Minister Nga Kor Ming.  Read more at https://tinyurl.com/2p8jp3hv  WATCH MORE: https://thestartv.com/c/news SUBSCRIBE: https://cutt.ly/TheStar LIKE: https://fb.com/TheStarOnline

Transcript

00:00 [Erkang] Thank you for the response, Your Honour.

00:03 I would like to ask Your Honour, as the Minister of Religion,

00:08 this confusion and Islamophobia,

00:12 due to the misunderstanding of Islam,

00:15 not only among the people out there,

00:19 but even among the Ministers.

00:22 How many times have you made a posting,

00:24 and you mentioned the Taliban and so on,

00:27 and how many more?

00:28 Is there anything that you are trying to understand

00:32 among the Cabinet Ministers?

00:34 I refer to the ban on the Qunut Nazilah.

00:39 When we read about the Qunut Nazilah,

00:42 anyone who is oppressed,

00:45 including non-Muslims,

00:47 if he is oppressed, his prayer will remain silent.

00:50 The Prophet's hadith says,

00:51 [Arabic]

00:57 Your Honour,

00:58 Your Honour, I would like to ask,

01:01 such things should be handled by the Ministry of Religion,

01:10 especially the Cabinet Ministers,

01:11 to give a clear understanding.

01:13 Even among the Ministers,

01:14 because they do not understand,

01:15 that is why there is a ban on the Qunut Nazilah.

01:19 [Erkang] The Masharad Law, Article 36,

01:20 "The wrong assumptions are accused against an expert."

01:24 What was said by the Chief Executive,

01:27 who accused us of having a problem with the understanding,

01:30 and the issue of the egg and the eggshell,

01:32 and what he wanted to say,

01:33 is actually a bad assumption,

01:35 which cannot be denied.

01:38 So I ask the Speaker to make a ruling,

01:41 and ask the Chief Executive to withdraw what was said.

01:45 Chief Executive, do you want to make an explanation?

01:53 I refer to a post from Ngah Kho Meng,

01:58 "Schools are not a place for conflict,

02:01 understanding of extremism and violence,

02:03 on the contrary, it is a place for human rights."

02:05 That is a bad assumption.

02:06 You do not understand what he said.

02:07 And it is referred to a post from a preacher,

02:11 Firdaus Mohamad,

02:12 "It is enough, just admit the bad assumptions,

02:15 what you are trying to say is extremism."

02:17 Please withdraw it.

02:18 It is easy to understand.

02:19 They are wasting their money,

02:23 to free their children,

02:25 to create a community,

02:26 not like the communists,

02:28 who are in the government as a...

02:30 I have a ruling.

02:35 Listen to the explanation first.

02:38 You raise the...

02:40 Yes, I do not agree with what he brought.

02:42 He continues to slander.

02:44 Listen to the explanation first.

02:45 This is not a matter...

02:48 The explanation that continues to slander,

02:51 does not admit the wrong.

02:52 That is not a matter...

02:53 What he said is correct.

02:54 Use the space for explanation,

02:56 to continue slander, that is wrong.

02:58 Listen to the explanation first.

02:59 Yes, wait for the explanation to finish first,

03:01 then you can wake up to make other rules and conditions.

03:04 This is a rule and condition,

03:06 asking for an explanation,

03:07 people give explanations,

03:08 slander,

03:09 defiance.

03:10 Don't be afraid.

03:11 What is this?

03:12 Hurry up.

03:14 This is proof.

03:15 I will not withdraw.

03:16 What do you want to withdraw?

03:17 What I said.

03:18 What you said.

03:19 What wording do you want to withdraw?

03:20 Must be very specific.

03:21 I said,

03:22 does the minister know about this?

03:23 And does Jakim need to play a role,

03:24 to make the people aware?

03:25 I said,

03:26 does the minister know about this?

03:27 And does Jakim need to play a role,

03:28 to make the people aware?

03:29 I said,

03:30 does the minister know about this?

03:31 And does Jakim need to play a role,

03:32 to make the people aware?

03:33 I said,

03:34 does the minister know about this?

03:35 I said,

03:36 does the minister know about this?

03:37 I said,

03:38 does the minister know about this?

03:39 I said,

03:40 does the minister know about this?

03:41 I said,

03:42 does Jakim need to play a role,

03:43 to make the people aware?

03:44 I said,

03:45 does the minister know about this?

03:46 I said,

03:47 does the minister know about this?

03:48 I said,

03:49 does the minister know about this?

03:50 I said,

03:51 does the minister know about this?

03:52 I said,

03:53 does the minister know about this?

03:54 I said,

03:55 does the minister know about this?

03:56 I said,

03:57 does the minister know about this?

03:58 I said,

03:59 does the minister know about this?

04:00 I said,

04:01 does the minister know about this?

04:02 I said,

04:03 does the minister know about this?

04:04 I said,

04:05 does the minister know about this?

04:06 I said,

04:07 does the minister know about this?

04:08 I said,

04:09 does the minister know about this?

04:10 I said,

04:11 does the minister know about this?

04:12 I said,

04:13 does the minister know about this?

04:14 I said,

04:15 does the minister know about this?

04:16 I said,

04:17 does the minister know about this?

04:18 I said,

04:19 does the minister know about this?

04:20 I said,

04:21 does the minister know about this?

04:22 I said,

04:23 does the minister know about this?

04:24 I said,

04:25 does the minister know about this?

04:26 I said,

04:27 does the minister know about this?

04:28 I said,

04:29 does the minister know about this?

04:30 I said,

04:31 does the minister know about this?

04:32 I said,

04:33 does the minister know about this?

04:34 I said,

04:35 does the minister know about this?

04:36 I said,

04:37 does the minister know about this?

04:38 I said,

04:39 does the minister know about this?

04:40 I said,

04:41 does the minister know about this?

04:42 I said,

04:43 does the minister know about this?

04:44 I said,

04:45 does the minister know about this?

04:46 I said,

04:47 does the minister know about this?

04:48 I said,

04:49 does the minister know about this?

04:50 I said,

04:51 does the minister know about this?

04:52 I said,

04:53 does the minister know about this?

04:54 I said,

04:55 does the minister know about this?

04:56 I said,

04:57 does the minister know about this?

04:58 I said,

04:59 does the minister know about this?

05:00 I said,

05:01 does the minister know about this?

05:02 I said,

05:03 does the minister know about this?

05:04 I said,

05:05 does the minister know about this?

05:06 I said,

05:07 does the minister know about this?

05:08 I said,

05:09 [BLANK_AUDIO]

Category

Transcript

Recommended