Court rejects plea to free detained lawmakers on bail
- 5 years ago
– Lawmakers who were detained after facing hate speech charges will remain behind bars after the High Court rejected pleas to release them on bail.
The ruling was issued after five CORD lawmakers filed an urgent application in the High Court for release on bail.
Overview
National Assembly CORD Members Aisha Jumwa (Kilifi Woman Representative), Florence Mutua (Busia Woman Representative), Junet Mohammed (Suna East) and Timothy Bosire (Kitutu Masaba) are being held alongside Senator Johnson Muthama (Machakos) for alleged hate speech
The lawmakers said the magistrate who detained them misapplied and improperly invoked the Constitution on the question as to whether there existed sufficient grounds to detain them pending investigations
The MPs were ordered to be held until June 17 when they are due back in court
Also seeking release on bail was University of Nairobi student leader Babu Owino.
Justice Joseph Onguto who heard submissions from defence lawyers led by James Orengo dismissed it without giving reasons, saying he would outline the basis for turning down the petition on Thursday.
Prosecuting Counsel Dr Leonard Maingi urged the court to dismiss the application arguing that “to seek orders of release on bail while the Chief Magistrate’s order is still subsisting is an abuse of the court process and unprocedural.”
The prosecutor told the court that in ordering pre-detention, Nairobi Chief Magistrate Daniel Ogembo had considered public interest and safety.
Regarding complaints by petitioners that they have been denied access to counsel, family and food, the prosecutor promised to liaise with the respective police stations to ensure access.
National Assembly CORD Members Aisha Jumwa (Kilifi Woman Representative), Florence Mutua (Busia Woman Representative), Junet Mohammed (Suna East) and Timothy Bosire (Kitutu Masaba) are being held alongside Senator Johnson Muthama (Machakos) for alleged hate speech.
The ruling was issued after five CORD lawmakers filed an urgent application in the High Court for release on bail.
Overview
National Assembly CORD Members Aisha Jumwa (Kilifi Woman Representative), Florence Mutua (Busia Woman Representative), Junet Mohammed (Suna East) and Timothy Bosire (Kitutu Masaba) are being held alongside Senator Johnson Muthama (Machakos) for alleged hate speech
The lawmakers said the magistrate who detained them misapplied and improperly invoked the Constitution on the question as to whether there existed sufficient grounds to detain them pending investigations
The MPs were ordered to be held until June 17 when they are due back in court
Also seeking release on bail was University of Nairobi student leader Babu Owino.
Justice Joseph Onguto who heard submissions from defence lawyers led by James Orengo dismissed it without giving reasons, saying he would outline the basis for turning down the petition on Thursday.
Prosecuting Counsel Dr Leonard Maingi urged the court to dismiss the application arguing that “to seek orders of release on bail while the Chief Magistrate’s order is still subsisting is an abuse of the court process and unprocedural.”
The prosecutor told the court that in ordering pre-detention, Nairobi Chief Magistrate Daniel Ogembo had considered public interest and safety.
Regarding complaints by petitioners that they have been denied access to counsel, family and food, the prosecutor promised to liaise with the respective police stations to ensure access.
National Assembly CORD Members Aisha Jumwa (Kilifi Woman Representative), Florence Mutua (Busia Woman Representative), Junet Mohammed (Suna East) and Timothy Bosire (Kitutu Masaba) are being held alongside Senator Johnson Muthama (Machakos) for alleged hate speech.