As President Obama appoints an official to edge the closing of the facility, we ask if any real progress is being made? Shihab Rattansi discusses with guests: David Remes, the legal director of Appeal for Justice, a human rights and civil liberties litigation firm who represents 18 Guantanamo detainees; Carlos Warner, a federal public defender who represents 11 Guantanamo prisoners; PJ Crowley who has served as US assistant secretary of state for public affairs between 2009 and 2011.